Broker transparency rule: your right to see the record under 371.3
By Rafael Fox · Updated October 2026
Carriers have had a right to see a broker's record of their load since 1980. Most never use it, and many sign it away without noticing. This guide explains what the rule actually says, how waiver clauses work, how to ask for the record, and where FMCSA's proposal to strengthen it stands, with each fact dated.
What 49 CFR 371.3 says
A broker must keep a record of each transaction, keep it for three years, and let each party to the transaction review it . The rule spells out what the record must show :
| Item | Why it matters to a carrier |
|---|---|
| Name and address of the consignor (shipper) | Who the freight belonged to |
| Name, address and registration number of the originating carrier | Confirms which carrier the broker recorded |
| Bill of lading or freight bill number | Ties the record to your load |
| Broker's compensation for the brokerage service, and who paid it | Shows what the broker earned on the load |
| Any non-brokerage services, their compensation and payer | Other charges the broker collected |
| Freight charges collected by the broker and the date paid to the carrier | What the broker collected and when it paid you |
Put together, the record lets a carrier see the gap between what the shipper paid and what the carrier received. Here is how that gap looks on an EXAMPLE load. Move the rates to see how the split changes.
Where the shipper's money goes
EXAMPLE- Shipper pays
- $2,600
- Carrier rate
- $2,150
- Broker margin
- $450 (17.3%)
Knowing the gap on one load won't tell you whether a broker is fair overall; margins swing load to load. Over many loads, it shows how much room there is to negotiate. Our guide to freight broker profit margin explains what typical margins look like and what public brokers report, and the broker margin calculator estimates the spread on a load you're offered.
Who counts as a party
The right belongs to each party to the brokered transaction. On a typical load that means the shipper that paid the broker and the carrier that hauled the freight. A dispatcher working for the carrier isn't a party to the brokered transaction in its own right, so a request should come from the carrier, in the carrier's name, even if the dispatcher helps write it. If you're unsure whether someone else in the chain counts, such as a factoring company that bought your invoice, ask a transportation attorney.
What the record won't show
The record is about money and identity, not performance. It won't show how the broker priced the load, whether the shipper paid on time, what the broker's costs were, or why your rate was what it was. It also covers the broker's compensation, not necessarily the shipper's full freight bill if the broker billed other services separately; non-brokerage services are listed as their own item. Read it as one load's numbers, not a verdict on the broker.
Why brokers resist
It helps to understand the other side. Brokers argue that shipper pricing is confidential to their customers, that showing margins load by load invites carriers to go around them, and that producing records on request is extra paperwork. Carriers and their associations argue that the rule already exists and that waivers empty it of meaning. FMCSA's proposal sits between the two. Knowing both arguments helps when you ask a broker to remove a waiver: a calm request is more likely to work than an accusation.
Waivers in broker agreements
The current rule gives the right but doesn't forbid giving it up, and many broker-carrier agreements include a waiver. Typical wording looks like this EXAMPLE:
"Carrier waives any right it may have to review Broker's records under 49 CFR 371.3." (EXAMPLE wording)
Waivers show up in the main agreement, in setup portals' click-through terms, and sometimes on rate cons. FMCSA's own proposal notes that contracts between brokers and carriers frequently contain these waivers .
- Look for it before you sign. Search the agreement for "371.3", "records" or "waive".
- Ask to strike it. Some brokers will remove it if asked, especially smaller ones.
- Decide what it's worth. For most loads, a waiver changes little; for a long relationship on a big lane, the right to see the record may matter more.
Waivers are one of several clauses worth checking; the full audit is in the broker-carrier agreement red flags checklist.
How to request the record
If you haven't waived the right, ask in writing. Identify the load clearly, cite the rule, and keep a copy. Here is an EXAMPLE letter you can copy and fill in:
EXAMPLE request letter
Subject: Request to review transaction record under 49 CFR 371.3 To: [Broker legal name], MC [number] We hauled the following load for you as the carrier: Load / PO number: [number] Pickup date: [date] Delivery date: [date] Bill of lading number: [number] Under 49 CFR 371.3(c), each party to a brokered transaction has the right to review the broker's record of the transaction. Please provide a copy of the record for this load, including the compensation you received for the brokerage service and the name of the payer, and any freight charges you collected and the date of payment to us. Please send it to [email] within [number] business days. Thank you. [Name], [Title] [Carrier legal name], MC [number], USDOT [number] [Phone]
Send it to the broker's billing or compliance contact and keep proof of sending. The current rule doesn't set a deadline for the broker to respond, so give a reasonable date and follow up. If the broker refuses and you didn't waive the right, you can file a complaint with FMCSA's complaint database .
Timing matters. Records only have to be kept for three years, so request older loads sooner rather than later. And requesting a record on a load where payment is in dispute can be useful evidence, alongside the steps in how long freight brokers take to pay.
EXAMPLE: one record, one lesson
EXAMPLE: Carrier B hauled a weekly load for Broker A for six months at $2,150 a trip. Its agreement had no waiver, so it requested the record for one recent load. The record showed the shipper paid Broker A $2,900, a margin of $750, far wider than typical. Carrier B didn't accuse anyone. At the next rate review it asked for $2,450, citing its on-time record on the lane, and settled at $2,375. The record didn't set the rate; it told Carrier B there was room to ask. The numbers are made up.
Pending changes
| Date | Step | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Aug and Oct 2020 | OOIDA and SBTC petitions published for comment | Done |
| Nov 20, 2024 | FMCSA proposed rule, 89 FR 91648 | Proposed |
| Feb 18, 2025 | Comment period reopened, 90 FR 9702 | Done |
| As of Oct 29, 2026 | Final rule | Not published (pending) |
What's proposed: FMCSA says the rule would make clear that brokers have a regulatory obligation to provide transaction records to the parties on request, and would change the format and content of the records. The petitions asked for more, including automatic electronic records within 48 hours and an explicit ban on waivers; FMCSA says its proposal responds to them but differs from what was requested. Until a final rule is published, the current 371.3 applies as written, and waivers remain common. We'll update this page with the date when that changes.
You don't need the record to negotiate well. Knowing your cost per mile, the lane, and when to walk away does most of the work, and that's what our dispatch for better rates does on every load. We read the agreement, including any waiver, before you sign, and you confirm each load. Apply here.
Sources
49 CFR 371.3 via eCFR, checked October 29, 2026. Federal Register: Transparency in Property Broker Transactions, 89 FR 91648 (November 20, 2024) and 90 FR 9702 (February 18, 2025); petitions 85 FR 51145 and 85 FR 65898 (2020); docket FMCSA-2023-0257, checked October 29, 2026. General information, not legal advice.