TraceDispatch

Freight fraud: the numbers, the main schemes and how carriers check

By Rafael Fox · Updated October 2026

QUICK ANSWER
Freight fraud is growing in cost: CargoNet estimated cargo theft losses at nearly $725 million in 2025, up 60%, and TIA logged over 1,600 fraud reports in six months, up 65%. Carriers mostly meet five schemes: double brokering, fake brokers, stolen carrier identities, fictitious pickups and spoofed payment emails. Checking the public record and calling known numbers stops most of them.

Key takeaways

  • Thieves are taking fewer chances on cheap loads: CargoNet's 2025 events were flat, but the average theft was worth 36% more.
  • Brokers are victims too. In TIA's 2025 survey, 22% of respondents lost more than $200,000 to fraud in six months.
  • Most schemes depend on a fake identity: an email domain, a phone number, a stolen MC or a hijacked account.
  • The cheapest defense is the public record plus a call to a number you looked up yourself.

"Nearly $725 million in estimated cargo theft losses in 2025, up 60% in a year, on almost the same number of incidents."Figures: Verisk CargoNet, 2025 annual analysis

Freight fraud has moved from an occasional bad load to an organized business. This page gathers the published figures we could trace to a named publisher and date, 18 of them, then turns to what matters on a carrier's phone: the schemes, the checks and the places to report. We're a dispatch service working only for carriers, and checking brokers before every load is part of our daily work. We don't name or accuse any company here; scammers often borrow the names of honest ones.

Freight fraud statistics: the numbers

Grouped by publisher. Each figure links to its source through its tag. Survey percentages are shares of respondents, not of the whole industry, and the FBI figures cover all internet crime, not only freight.

Cargo theft

Verisk CargoNet, 2025 annual figures and Q2 2026

  • $725MEstimated cargo theft losses in the US and Canada in 2025, nearly, up 60% from 2024
  • 3,594Supply chain crime events recorded in 2025, against 3,607 in 2024
  • 2,646Confirmed cargo thefts in 2025, up 18% from 2,243
  • $273,990Average value per theft in 2025, up 36% from $202,364
  • 708Food and beverage thefts in 2025, up 47%, the largest increase by commodity
  • +77%Rise in metal theft in 2025, driven by demand for copper
  • $304.6MEstimated cargo losses in the second quarter of 2026 alone

Fraud against brokers and carriers

Transportation Intermediaries Association, April 2025 survey

  • 1,600+Fraud reports to TIA Watchdog from September 2024 to February 2025
  • +65%Increase in those reports over the previous period, despite two fewer months
  • 34%Of respondents named unlawful brokerage as the top fraud tactic they face
  • 83%Experienced at least three types of fraud in six months
  • 97%Named truckload as the most fraud-prone mode
  • 22%Reported losing more than $200,000 to fraud in six months
  • 10%Spent more than $200,000 on fraud prevention

Internet crime overall

FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 report

  • 1,008,597Internet crime complaints to IC3 in 2025, all industries
  • $20.877BLosses reported to IC3 in 2025, all industries
  • 24,768Business email compromise complaints in 2025
  • $3.05BBusiness email compromise losses in 2025, the scheme behind most spoofed-email payment fraud

Chart: cargo theft, 2024 vs 2025

Confirmed thefts and average value per theft, US and Canada (Verisk CargoNet)

Confirmed thefts

20242,243
20252,646

Average value per theft

2024$202,364
2025$273,990

Chart: what brokers reported to TIA

Share of respondents, TIA State of Fraud in the Industry, April 2025
  • Truckload is the most fraud-prone mode97%
  • Saw three or more fraud types in six months83%
  • Unlawful brokerage is the top tactic34%
  • Lost over $200,000 in six months22%
  • Spent over $200,000 on prevention10%

Two cautions on reading these. Counts depend on reporting: many victims never report, and different groups count different things, so CargoNet's theft events, TIA's fraud reports and IC3's complaints can't be added together. And growth in losses isn't the same as growth in incidents. CargoNet's 2025 numbers show flat events with much larger losses, which points to thieves choosing higher-value freight.

Why should a carrier care about cargo theft totals? Because theft and fraud come back to carriers in several ways: an identity used to steal a load, a payment that never arrives, slower setup as brokers add checks, and higher cargo insurance costs as insurers price the risk. The numbers above are the background to every extra document a broker asks you for.

Why freight fraud grew

Several things lined up. Booking freight moved almost entirely to email, load boards and apps, so a broker and a carrier can complete a load without ever hearing each other's voices. Operating authority was easy to obtain and, until recently, the registration system did little to verify who was behind an application. Rate confirmations, bills of lading and certificates are PDFs that can be edited in minutes. And a single load of electronics, copper or food can be worth more than a year of small scams.

The rules are catching up in places. FMCSA's new registration system, Motus, adds identity verification for applicants , and broker security rules in force since January 16, 2026 make a broker's $75,000 bond or trust easier to reach and trigger suspension faster when it's drawn down . None of that replaces checking each load yourself.

Five schemes carriers meet

Every example below is an EXAMPLE with made-up names. Real cases mix and match these patterns.

1. Double brokering

EXAMPLE: Carrier B books a load from "Broker Z," hauls it, and is never paid. The shipper's paperwork names Broker A, which paid someone else. An extra link in the chain took the money. Add that link yourself below and see what changes; the full guide is double brokering freight.

Carrier

Hauls the load under its own MC and signs the rate confirmation.

Paid by the broker (or through a factor) at the carrier rate.

2. Fake brokers using a real name

EXAMPLE: An email arrives from a domain one letter off a real brokerage, with a real MC number in the signature and a phone number that isn't in FMCSA's record. The rate is attractive. The "broker" never pays, and the real company never heard of the load. Checking the contact details against the public record catches this one.

What stops it: call the brokerage on the number FMCSA lists for that MC and ask whether the person who emailed you works there and posted that load.

3. Your own identity stolen

EXAMPLE: Carrier C finds that someone changed the email and phone on its FMCSA record and is booking loads in its name. Brokers think they're dealing with Carrier C; the loads disappear. Prevention and recovery are in carrier identity theft and MC hijacking prevention.

What stops it: secure the email account tied to your FMCSA record, turn on two-factor sign-in, and check your record regularly so a change is spotted in days, not months.

4. Fictitious pickups

EXAMPLE: A thief books a load with a broker using a stolen or fake carrier identity, shows up at the shipper with a truck, and the freight is never seen again. Carriers are hurt twice: their identity may be the one used, and the theft drives brokers to tighten setup for everyone.

What stops it: on the carrier side, the same identity protection as scheme 3; on the broker and shipper side, matching the truck, trailer and driver at the dock to what was booked.

5. Spoofed payment emails

EXAMPLE: After delivery, Carrier D's factoring company gets an email "from Carrier D" asking to send payments to a new bank account. The email account was hijacked through a phishing link. This is the freight version of business email compromise, which the FBI counted at over $3 billion in losses across all industries in 2025.

What stops it: tell your factor and brokers in writing that payment details never change by email alone, and confirm any change by phone to a number already on file.

Look at what the five have in common. Each one needs the victim to trust an identity without checking it: an email address, a phone number, an MC number, a truck at the dock, a request in an inbox. That's good news, because identity is the one thing a carrier can check in minutes before anything moves.

What brokers do on their side

Fraud costs brokers too, and the careful ones have changed how they work. Many now verify a carrier's identity before setup, compare the truck and driver at pickup with what was booked, track loads in transit, and pay only the carrier named on their rate con and its verified factoring company. Some of those steps slow carrier setup down. When a broker asks for extra documents or a quick video call, it's usually protecting your freight and your name as much as its own.

The checks that stop most freight fraud

Five checks and the schemes they catch
CheckCatches
Look up the MC or USDOT in FMCSA's record; authority active, bond on fileFake brokers, unbonded double brokers
Call the number in the record, not the one in the emailImpersonation, spoofed domains
Match the rate con broker to the shipper's BOL and pickup numberDouble brokering
Confirm any payment change by phone to a known numberPayment redirection
Two-factor sign-in on email, load boards and factoring; watch your own FMCSA recordIdentity theft, hijacked accounts

Start every new broker with our DOT and MC number lookup, then follow the full process in how to vet a freight broker. Two habits matter more than any tool: slow down when someone pushes you to commit right now, and treat any request to change a payment detail as suspicious until a phone call to a known number confirms it.

Where to report freight fraud

  • FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center for online fraud, phishing and payment redirection .
  • FMCSA National Consumer Complaint Database for problems involving a registered broker or carrier .
  • Local police right away for stolen cargo or equipment, with the load details and any tracking data.
  • The load board, your factoring company and your bank, so accounts can be frozen and others warned.
  • The real company being impersonated, using contact details from the public record.

Fast reports help. Banks can sometimes stop a transfer only in the first hours, and a load board can pull a fake account before it books more freight. Keep copies of every email with full headers, every rate con and every call log.

The first 24 hours

  1. Stop: don't load, unload, pay or change anything else until you know who you're dealing with.
  2. Call your bank and factoring company if money or payment details are involved, and ask them to hold or recall transfers.
  3. Change passwords and turn on two-factor sign-in for email, load boards and your FMCSA account if an account was used.
  4. File the police report for stolen cargo, and the IC3 and FMCSA reports, and note the report numbers.
  5. Tell the real broker, carrier or shipper whose name was used, on contact details from the public record.
  6. Check your own FMCSA record for changes you didn't make, and fix them through FMCSA.

Recovery isn't guaranteed, and some losses become a legal question between the parties. A transportation attorney can tell you whether a bond claim or a lawsuit makes sense for your case.

For carriers running time-critical freight, where fraudsters push hardest on speed, our page on expedited dispatch explains how we handle urgent loads without skipping the checks. If you'd like us to do the checking for every load, apply here.

Sources

Verisk CargoNet 2025 annual analysis, reported by DC Velocity, January 2026. Verisk CargoNet Q2 2026 figures, reported by FreightWaves, August 7, 2026. Transportation Intermediaries Association, State of Fraud in the Industry, April 2025. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 Internet Crime Report, April 2026. FMCSA National Consumer Complaint Database. All checked October 29, 2026. This guide is general information, not legal advice.

Freight fraud: common questions

How common is freight fraud?
Very. TIA's Watchdog logged more than 1,600 fraud reports from September 2024 to February 2025, up 65%, and 83% of its surveyed members saw at least three kinds of fraud in six months. CargoNet counted 2,646 confirmed cargo thefts in the US and Canada in 2025. Most fraud never gets reported publicly, so every count is a floor, not a total.
What are the most common freight scams?
For carriers: double brokering, people posing as real brokers, theft of the carrier's own identity and MC, fictitious pickups where a fake carrier steals the load, and spoofed emails that redirect payments. In TIA's 2025 survey, unlawful brokerage was the top tactic named by members. Most schemes start with a fake email, a fake phone number or a hijacked account.
How do I report freight fraud?
Report it to the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov, and to FMCSA's National Consumer Complaint Database for problems involving a registered broker or carrier. Report stolen cargo to local police right away. Tell the load board, your factoring company and the real broker or carrier being impersonated, so they can warn others and freeze accounts.
How do carriers protect themselves from fraud?
Check every new broker in FMCSA's public record, then call it on the number in that record, not the number in the email. Match the rate con, the BOL and the pickup details. Never change payment details because of an email. Use two-factor sign-in on load boards, email and factoring accounts, and watch your own FMCSA record for changes you didn't make.
Is freight fraud increasing?
The published numbers say losses are. CargoNet's estimated cargo theft losses rose 60% in 2025 to nearly $725 million even though total events were flat, meaning thieves are targeting higher-value loads. TIA's fraud reports rose 65% in its 2025 period. Totals depend on what gets reported, so read each figure with its publisher and date.

Want a second set of eyes on every broker?

We dispatch for carriers only. We check the broker's public records before we offer a load; the rate con comes straight from the broker to you, and you confirm or pass.

We work for this link

Carrier

Hauls the load under its own MC and signs the rate confirmation.

Paid by the broker (or through a factor) at the carrier rate.