How to vet a freight broker in 10 minutes, before you book
By Rafael Fox · Updated October 2026
Ten minutes of checking before you book costs less than one unpaid load after.
Most advice on vetting is written for brokers checking carriers. This guide is the other direction: how a carrier, or a dispatcher working for one, checks a broker before a truck moves. The checks below are the ones we run on the carrier side. Each rule carries its source, and the checklist saves your progress on this device so you can work through it with a broker on the phone.
One principle runs through all of it: records, not reputations. A public record can confirm who a broker is and what it has on file. It can't tell you whether a broker pays on time, and a scammer using a real broker's name says nothing bad about the real broker. Check identity with records, then judge payment on facts.
The 10-minute check, step by step
Seven steps, in this order. The minute markers are rough; with practice the whole check takes less.
Get the MC number and look it up
Ask for the MC or USDOT number before you talk rate. Look it up in FMCSA's public records or our DOT and MC number lookup. Confirm the record shows active broker authority; a carrier-only authority can't legally broker your load .
Confirm the bond or trust
The record should show a BMC-84 bond or BMC-85 trust on file for $75,000, with no cancellation pending . No security on file means no broker authority, and nothing to claim against if you aren't paid.
Match the name to the record and the website
The legal or DBA name on the rate con should match the record. Find the broker's own website by searching its name, not by clicking a link in the email, and compare the address and phone with the record.
Check the email domain
The sender's domain should match the broker's website exactly. Watch for an extra letter, a swapped character, a different ending, or a free email account for a company that has its own domain.
Call back on a number you found
Call the number from the public record or the broker's website and ask for the person who contacted you. Ask them to confirm the load and the pickup number. This one call defeats most impersonation.
Read the rate con terms
Before you agree: the rate, the pickup and delivery details, detention and layover, TONU, fines and chargebacks, and anything that conflicts with your broker-carrier agreement. Our guide to the rate confirmation covers each clause.
Check payment terms and credit
Note the standard terms, quick pay fees and how invoices are sent. If you factor, ask your factor whether it will buy invoices on this broker. Then decide, and write down what you checked.
The order matters. Identity first, because a perfect rate from a fake broker is worth nothing. Then the terms, because a real broker with bad terms can still cost you money. Payment last, because that check depends on knowing exactly which company you're dealing with.
Reading the record carefully
A quick glance at the record can miss things. A few points that matter:
- Authority type. A company can hold carrier authority, broker authority or both, each with its own status. You need the broker authority to be active. A carrier-only company offering you a load it won't haul is brokering without authority .
- Status words. Active is what you want. Pending means the authority isn't granted yet. Inactive, revoked or suspended means the broker can't legally broker your load today.
- Legal name and DBA. Many brokers trade under a different name. The rate con may show either, but it must tie back to the same record.
- Contact details. The phone and email on the record are what the broker gave FMCSA. A mismatch with the person calling you is the most common sign of impersonation.
- Bond details. The filing names the surety or trustee. Note it; if you ever need to claim, that's who you contact .
Questions to ask on the phone
A short call with a real broker answers most of these in a minute. A fake one tends to stall:
- What is your MC number, and is this load booked under it?
- Who is the shipper, and what's the pickup number?
- Is this load exclusive to my truck, or will anything be added?
- What are your detention, layover and TONU terms on this load?
- What are your payment terms, and where do invoices go?
A note on new brokers
A broker whose authority was granted recently isn't a red flag by itself; every brokerage was new once. FMCSA's new registration system adds identity verification for applicants , which helps. But a very new authority combined with a rate far above the lane and pressure to commit fast is a pattern worth a second call. Start a new broker with one load and see how it pays.
Interactive vetting checklist
Tick each item as you go. Your progress is saved on this device. Print it or save it as a PDF to keep with the load file.
Broker vetting checklist
0 of 10 checked
What records can't tell you
Here is the check run on an EXAMPLE broker. Notice the last line: some answers aren't in any public record.
Broker check: Broker A
EXAMPLE- Broker authority is activeCheckedFMCSA registration shows active broker authority.
- Bond or trust on fileCheckedFinancial security filing shows as on file in the public record.
- Name and MC match the callerVerified by phoneWe call back on the number from the broker's own website, not the one in the email.
- Email domain matches the brokerCheckedLookalike domains (extra letters, free mail) end the conversation.
- Rate con terms in writingCheckedDetention, TONU, payment terms and fines read before you see the offer.
- Payment terms and quick pay feeCheckedStandard terms and quick-pay cost confirmed with the broker.
- Payment habitsNot in recordsPublic records don't show this. We use the broker's published terms, factoring credit checks if you factor, and our own history with them.
What records can't tell you is in the last line.
| Question | In FMCSA's record? | Where to look instead |
|---|---|---|
| Is broker authority active? | Yes | n/a |
| Is a bond or trust on file? | Yes | n/a |
| Is the caller really from this broker? | No | Call back on the number in the record or on the website |
| Does it pay on time? | No | Your factor's credit check, days-to-pay services, other carriers |
| Will it pay detention? | No | The rate con and broker-carrier agreement, in writing |
| Does it re-broker loads? | No | The BOL and pickup details, and the agreement's no-rebrokering clause |
Payment habits are the biggest gap. Federal rules require brokers to keep a record of each transaction, and each party can review it , but that's after the fact. Before the load, your best signals are your factor's willingness to buy the invoice, what carriers you trust have seen, and the broker's own written terms. If you've run for a broker before, your own records are the best data of all.
Intent is the other gap. A record can't show whether a real broker plans to pass your load to someone else, or whether the person on the phone is who they claim. Our guide to double brokering freight covers how to spot the extra link.
EXAMPLE: two offers, one afternoon
EXAMPLE: Carrier B has two offers for the same truck on the same day. Broker A offers a fair rate; Broker Z offers 20% more. Here is what ten minutes of checking found.
| Check | Broker A | Broker Z |
|---|---|---|
| Broker authority | Active, several years | Active, granted weeks ago |
| Bond or trust | BMC-84 on file | None on file |
| Email domain | Matches website | Free email account |
| Callback on public number | Contact confirmed the load | Number in record unanswered |
| Rate con | Standard terms, detention listed | Not sent until truck is "on the way" |
| Factor approval | Approved | Factor won't buy |
The extra 20% from Broker Z isn't money if it never arrives. With no bond on file, Broker Z shouldn't be brokering at all, and there would be nothing to claim against. Carrier B takes Broker A's load. The example is made up; the pattern is common.
How to run a free freight broker credit check
A broker credit check looks at payment behavior, which the public record doesn't cover. Here are the real options, described from each provider's own pages as of October 29, 2026:
| Source | What it shows | Cost to a carrier |
|---|---|---|
| FMCSA public records | Authority status, bond or trust on file, contact details; no payment data | Free |
| DAT load boards | Brokers' average days to pay, credit scores and customer reviews, per DAT's load board page | Included in DAT load board subscriptions |
| Truckstop load board | Broker credit and days-to-pay, listed in its Pro plan | Included in the Pro subscription |
| Your factoring company | Whether it will buy invoices on a broker, based on its own credit review | Usually part of factoring service; ask yours |
| Your own records | How each broker has paid you | Free |
So a truly free credit check is a combination: the public record for identity and the bond, your factor's approval if you factor, and your own payment history. Load board credit data is useful but comes with a paid subscription. A broker credit score is a guide, not a guarantee; a high score with slow recent payments to you still deserves a question. Our broker days-to-pay tracker builds your own history in your browser.
Signs a broker is not legit
- Contact details that don't match the public record or the broker's own website.
- A brand-new MC offering big, high-value loads right away.
- A rate far above what the lane is paying, with pressure to commit now.
- Any request to change payment details, or to pay a fee to get a load.
Red flags that end the call
Some findings mean stop, not "check further." If any of these come up, don't book:
- No broker authority in the record, or authority that is inactive, revoked or pending.
- No bond or trust on file, or a cancellation already in progress.
- The phone number or email domain doesn't match the record or the website, and the broker can't explain it.
- The person won't give an MC number or a callback number.
- You're told not to contact the shipper, or to use a different company name at pickup.
- The rate con arrives from a different company than the one you spoke to.
- Any request to send your payment or factoring details to a new address, or to pay a fee to get the load.
Two softer signs deserve a second look but not an automatic no: a rate well above the lane with heavy pressure to commit now, and payment terms much longer than you're used to. Ask questions, and walk away if the answers don't hold up.
When something doesn't match after you've loaded
Sometimes the mismatch only shows up at the dock: the shipper's bill of lading names a different broker, or the pickup number doesn't match your rate con. Don't leave until you've called the broker on your rate con and, if needed, the broker named on the BOL, using numbers from the public record. Tell the shipper what you're seeing; shippers would much rather wait ten minutes than lose a load. If it can't be sorted out, it's safer to leave empty than to haul a load nobody will pay you for. Note every call in your log.
After the check: setup, agreement and rate con
Passing the check gets you to the paperwork, and the paperwork is where good brokers and bad terms both show up. The broker will send a setup packet; our guide to new carrier setup explains what's in it. It will ask you to sign a broker-carrier agreement, which governs every load after; read the broker-carrier agreement guide and keep the agreement red flags checklist open while you do. If you use a dispatcher, the contract between you matters too; see dispatch contract clauses.
Then each load gets its own rate con. Read it every time, even with brokers you know. Terms change, and a rate con that conflicts with your agreement usually wins for that load.
Rechecking brokers you already use
Vetting isn't one and done. Authority can be suspended, a bond can be cancelled, and a hijacked email account can turn a broker you trust into a channel for fraud overnight. Recheck the record when you haven't worked with a broker for a few months, whenever the contact person, phone number or email address changes, whenever you're asked to change how invoices or payments are handled, and whenever payment slows down. A quick look at the record before a large or unusual load is cheap insurance.
Since January 2026, when claim payments drop a broker's bond or trust below $75,000, FMCSA moves to suspend the broker within 7 business days unless it's restored . A broker you checked last month may not be in good standing this month.
Keep a vetting log
Write down what you checked, when, and what you found: the MC, the authority and bond status, who you spoke to and on which number, and the rate con you received. It takes a minute per load. If a load goes wrong, that log is the first thing your factor, a surety or an attorney will want, and it shows you did your part. It also builds your own payment history on each broker, which is the data no public record will give you.
Building on good brokers
Vetting isn't only about keeping bad brokers out. The brokers who pass, and then pay on time, are the ones worth building a relationship with. Our guide to broker relationships covers how carriers become the first call on repeat lanes. New authorities face extra hurdles at setup; brokers that work with new authority explains what brokers ask for and why. Some carriers work with brokers mostly by email; email brokers covers that channel, and how to get truck loads without a broker covers going direct to shippers.
How our desk does this on every load
On the carrier side, vetting is part of the job, not an extra. Before we offer a carrier any load, we pull the broker's public record, confirm authority and the bond or trust, and check that the contact matches the record. We read the rate con terms and flag anything unusual. Then we send the carrier the details, and the carrier decides: confirm, or pass with no penalty.
We never sign for the carrier. The broker sends the rate con straight to the carrier, who signs it in its own company name, and the broker pays the carrier or its factor directly. Freight money never passes through us. That's how our dispatch service works for every truck, every load. If you'd like the checking done for you, apply here.
If you use any dispatcher, ours or someone else's, ask how they vet brokers and whether they'll show you what they checked. A dispatcher who can't answer that, who signs rate cons for you, or who wants freight payments routed through their own account is a risk in its own right. The carrier is the one who gets hurt when a broker check is skipped, so the carrier should be able to see it was done.
Sources
49 CFR Part 371 and 49 CFR 387.307 via eCFR; 49 U.S.C. 14916 via govinfo; FMCSA notice on Motus, 91 FR 23144 (April 29, 2026); FMCSA National Consumer Complaint Database. All checked October 2026. Each rule links to its source through its tag. The examples are labeled EXAMPLE and use made-up names. This guide is general information, not legal advice.